Skirting heating - is it worth doing or not?
Discreet, efficient, comfortable heating. A very attractive combination of characteristics. A warm floor immediately comes to mind. And rightly so. But this is not the only heating method that meets these characteristics. There is also a warm plinth. The system is easier to install, most of it is available for maintenance at any time. So the heating plinth should also be considered as an option for invisible heating.
The content of the article
Warm skirting system: what is it
Heating skirting boards or skirting board heating are not new in the field of heating. The idea was proposed at the beginning of the last century, but due to the complexity of implementation and the high price, it was almost forgotten. With the development of technology, the complexity has become lower, but the price is still high. This is, in the main, and holds back potential users.
The main difference of this system is the non-standard form of heating devices and their unusual arrangement. Heaters are long and low, located around the perimeter of the room at floor level. The heaters are covered with a long decorative strip, which looks very much like a skirting board. When installing, replace the usual skirting board. Therefore, such a system is often called "warm skirting board". This system is very good for panoramic glazing - it can be no higher than the frames, so it is completely invisible. She is no worse in ordinary rooms - she is not visible at all.
Types of warm skirting boards
There are two types of warm skirting boards: electric and water. Electric warm skirting boards differ in that each heating device is independent and can work separately. They can be installed in the event of a lack of capacity of the main heating - as an additional one, in case of cold weather. The installation is simple, but it works efficiently, is invisible, does not dry the air too much.
There is a warm water baseboard. This is one of the subspecies of water heating, that is, all heating devices are connected into one system. It can be both the main (only skirting heaters) and an additional type of heating (together with underfloor heating or radiators).
Heating plinth device
In any case, a warm plinth looks like this: these are two copper pipes, which are at a distance of 7-15 cm from one another.To increase heat transfer, vertical plates made of aluminum, brass are put on the tubes (they cost a little less, but the heat transfer is slightly lower) or copper (more expensive and "warmer" option). The finned tubes are closed from above with decorative extruded aluminum covers. Aluminum was not chosen by chance - it transfers heat well. So the heated lid itself emits heat.
There are holes at the top and bottom of the cover for air movement. Cold is sucked in through the lower ones, heated through the upper ones. So it turns out that heating comes from three sources:
- The air is heated, which passes along the pipes and fins.
- From heated walls.
- From the body of a warm metal baseboard.
Such a triple heat source contributes to the fact that the room heats up quickly, and the location of the heating elements around the perimeter contributes to uniform heating of the air throughout the volume.
Advantages and disadvantages of plinth heating
What is the difference between heating using a warm baseboard? Warm air is drawn from the heating element upwards along the wall, warming up the wall. As you move up, the air gradually cools down, then descends, but not along the wall, but in the center of the room.
The result is that the warmest air is at the bottom of the room. The warmest object - apart from heaters - is the walls. Also warmer air is located at the floor. Rising up, it cools down and at head level it is slightly colder. The difference is small 1-2 degrees, but it is this temperature distribution that is better for a person's well-being.
Heating with a warm plinth is inertial. Unambiguously attributing this property to advantages or disadvantages will not work. There are both positive and negative aspects. Minus: until the walls warm up, the room is cool. Therefore, such a system is good only for permanent residences and is completely unsuitable for summer cottages. The positive thing is that when heated, the walls work as a large stabilizer - they maintain the temperature at the same level, giving off the accumulated heat if necessary. Such a large heat accumulator will help to hold out for some time even if the heating is turned off.
The advantages of a heating system with heating skirting boards include their efficiency. After the walls are heated, the boiler consumes a minimum of fuel - only to maintain the temperature. And such modes are usually more economical. But this applies to any inertial heating system, so this cannot be considered a special advantage of a warm skirting board.
There are plinth heating and undeniable advantages. The first is one of the few systems that provides uniform heating. Even the corners are always warm. The second is the most inconspicuous system that easily fits into any interior. At the same time, heating devices are easily accessible, the system can be repaired at any time.
It has a warm baseboard and a clear drawback - a high price. This is due to the fact that copper and aluminum are used to increase heat transfer, and they cost a lot.
Types of heating skirting boards
The baseboard heating system can be of two types: with electric and water heaters. At the installation stage, a system with warm water skirting boards is more complicated (a collector or beam connection is required), but during operation it is more economical. The electric warm skirting board is mounted quickly - you just need to fix the heaters to the wall, immediately after installation it is ready for use. But heating costs, like any electric heating, are high.
Heating device with hot water baseboard
The water baseboard heating system differs only in the non-standard form of heating devices. The key components do not differ from the standard ones: you need a hot water boiler, a manifold assembly and a pipe system with which a warm plinth is connected.
Please note: the optimal operating mode of the system is low temperature. On the flow 40-50 ° C, on the return about 5 ° C lower. Therefore, it is necessary to select a boiler or build a system based on this. If the boiler is gas, the best choice is condensing. When installing any other, the system requires a heat accumulator and / or a mixing unit - to reduce and stabilize the temperature.
Connection method
There are peculiarities in the choice of the connection method. Serial connection of all baseboard heaters in the room is ineffective: until the coolant reaches the last in the heater branch, it will cool down a lot and they will remain cold almost all the time.
For a water heating baseboard, a beam system is used: the devices are connected one by one or in pairs. To do this, a manifold unit is built into the system, to which pipes are connected that go to heating devices. The disadvantage of such a system is the high consumption of pipes. After all, two pipes go to each device (or a small group) - for supply and return. The pipe consumption is much higher, but the heat distribution is more even and the system itself is more reliable. Why is it more reliable? If pipes or radiators are damaged in one group, all the others work normally.
Installation features
When installing a water baseboard heating, pipes are usually hidden in the floor. It will not work to lay them along the walls, since the place is occupied by heating devices. That is, the installation of warm water baseboards is possible only at the stage of repair - you will have to raise the floors.
Special polymer pipes are recommended to be laid in a screed - they are not subject to corrosion and have low heat transfer, that is, heat losses during transportation of the coolant will be small. But since the availability of these systems for repair is not great, it is necessary to take quality goods from well-known manufacturers, and this is not cheap.
Electric warm skirting board
An electric warm plinth externally differs from a water one only in the presence of terminals for connecting power. The rest is the same. They are two tubes with perpendicularly fixed aluminum / brass / copper plates. A heating element - heating element is located in the lower tube, wires for connection are laid in the upper tube.
It is much easier to mount and connect an electric warm skirting board. You just need to fix it, stretch the wires and connect them to the terminals. To maintain the set temperature, a thermostat is built into the system, which turns on and off the heaters. The use of thermostats is desirable, as it optimizes operation - it saves electricity.
The installation is really simple, but it is necessary to connect an electric warm plinth to a dedicated line with a correctly selected rating of the circuit breaker and copper single-core wires of the appropriate section. So, in this case, repairs are required - it is customary to lay the wiring in the wall, and for this you need to do grooves, that is, breaking walls.
Installation of a hot water baseboard system
Installation of electric warm skirting board is very simple: we fix it on the wall. That's it, the system is ready for use. It remains to plug in the sockets. The main thing is that it is correctly calculated wire section, stood circuit breakers of the correct rating... This is the main problem when using an electric warm skirting board. The water one is much more difficult to mount. Everything must be collected into a single system, and this is not easy.
Calculation of baseboard heating
A complete heat engineering calculation of heating is a long and complicated matter. The size and geometry of the room, the material of the walls, floor, ceiling are taken into account, the degree of insulation of all structural elements, including windows and doors, is taken into account. In general, the calculation is not easy at all. Therefore, most often they take the average figure, which is derived from the analysis of many calculations.
It is believed that to heat one square meter of the area of a room with an average insulation, 100 W of thermal energy is needed. That is, to calculate the power of a warm plinth, you need to multiply the area of the room by 100. Get the required figure. This is exactly how much (or better, about 20-25% more) that all elements of a warm plinth should add up to.
For example, the area of a room is 18 square meters. It needs 1800 watts to heat it. Next, we look at how much heat is emitted by one meter of heating.The water heating plinth can work in different modes, depending on the mode, it emits a different amount of heat. The table above shows data for one of the systems. For example, let's take the heat dissipation of one meter of a warm plinth from this table (other manufacturers may have significant differences).
For example, the system will operate with a supply temperature of 50 ° C. Then one running meter produces 132 W of heat. To heat this room, you will need 1800/132 = 13.6 m of warm plinth. When ordering, it is better to add 20-25% stock. This margin is necessary so that the system does not work all the time at the limit. This time. And also in case of abnormal cold weather. These are two. So, we take 17 meters with a margin.
Once again, we draw your attention: this is the average data for some average house. And even the height of the ceilings is not taken into account here. She again took the average - 2.5 meters. If you have better insulation, you will need less heat, if worse than "average" - more. In general, this method gives only rough estimates.
How to proceed
The first thing to do is to draw a plan on which to indicate the length of each heating device, the length of the connecting pipes. After all, the length of a warm plinth is not always equal to the perimeter of the room. In this case, the segments of the heating devices are interconnected with copper or polymer pipes. It is undesirable to use steel, as they chemically interact with copper (it is gradually destroyed).
Preparation for the installation takes place long before its actual start. At the very beginning of the repair, even before the floor is leveled, pipes are drawn from the boiler or manifold assembly to the connection point of the warm plinth. The pipes are laid, tested for integrity, filled with a screed in a filled state under pressure (the working pressure in a private house is 2-3 atm, in a multi-storey house it is necessary to find out in the housing office). Then, all the repair work is carried out, and only after finishing the walls and floor, the installation of a warm plinth begins. Here is its order:
- Heat-reflecting tape is attached around the perimeter of the walls. It prevents heat consumption for wall heating.
- Fasteners are installed on top of the tape with a pitch of 50-60 cm. They are fixed to the wall using dowels or self-tapping screws (depending on the wall material).
- In the fasteners, according to the plan, sections of the heating plinth are fixed, interconnected with copper or polymer pipes.
- The tightness of the system is checked using crimping.
- If everything is normal, pipes from the manifold unit or from the boiler are connected, the system is filled with coolant and tested.
- After successful tests, the decorative covers are installed and the baseboard heating system is ready for use.
Actually, the installation of warm skirting boards is not too difficult. But the tightness of the joints is important and special attention must be paid to this.
Last year, a foreman who was doing repairs in my house convinced me to install an electric heating system "warm skirting" in my house and I am very grateful to him for this. Firstly: this system is much more economical than the same warm floor, it consumes much less electricity. Secondly: the room is very quickly filled with warmth when the system is turned on, there is no need to wait a couple of hours.Thirdly: durability, only the best materials are used in a warm skirting board: thus, the heating module is copper and brass, and the outer profile is hot-pressed, besides shock-resistant aluminum with a thickness of at least 2 mm. Since the warm plinth is located along the walls, the heated air slowly rises along the walls, heating their surface, as a result, a warm screen is formed along the windows and outer walls that prevents heat from escaping outside and thereby reliably insulates the entire room. My whole family was very happy and does not freeze in the cold season, and the Warm Plinth system can be turned on and off whenever you like.
Hello!
When designing a new apartment, she enthusiastically began to be interested in novelties, subscribed to various blogs on Instagram. My husband was engaged in the repair, but on some points I asked him to listen to me. In addition, I wanted to put a warm plinth in the living room, in a place where people are constantly, and in particular I am with children, in the absence of my husband at work. I read the charms about 50% humidity and that was the main motive. There was no talk of installation throughout the apartment, since we did not know, we did not feel how it works before. When choosing between an electric floor heating and a warm water baseboard, we stopped at the latter, because in addition to humidity it is still installed on any surface floor. By the way, if it weren't for Insta, I don't think I found out about it. It all happened by chance. But as they say, whatever is done is for the best. I would have known at the time of choosing a warm skirting board better. they would also put it in the nursery, where in winter it is significantly uncomfortable compared to the living room.
I will say the following, parents. if a warm plinth was the default in kindergartens, where in winter there is no air at all with these radiators, our children would be much healthier and would not have to sit with them on sick leave. There is all the infection.
There is something to compare. Not cheap, but in a certain sense you can say that health can be bought. If possible, do not hesitate.
How great it would be. if a warm plinth stood in kindergartens
As for me, ideally for kindergartens, a water-heated floor is better.
If it is done at the construction stage, then it is probably better, but if you modernize the heating system without dismantling the floor covering, then there is only an option with a baseboard.
Vera, thanks for the detailed feedback! Tell me, which manufacturer's warm plinth was installed? What pipes were used?
A friend praised "Mr. Tectum" trade mark "Mr. Tektum "- Heating system. Claims that the quality is quite acceptable. At the installation stage, the installer did not identify any visible jambs; during the heating season, nothing came out either. A small crack is acceptable, since materials with different thermal expansion are used in the manufacture. The manufacturer is Russian, but as I understand it, the production is its own and quite modern.
My opinion about warm skirting boards is that the system will be very appropriate for panoramic glazing (when there is no way to hang radiators) and in corner apartments of the old housing stock, where freezing of corners and mold is common. At one time, a neighbor solved this issue by hanging an additional radiator in the corner, but I think the plinth will do.
Hello everybody! There are a lot of plastic pipes in stock, can it be used for a water baseboard?
Someone uses metal-plastic and everything seems to be fine, but personally I am against such experiments. It is better to buy good quality cross-linked polyethylene, for example, from the German company REHAU.
Sergey, thanks for the advice!
I ask those who use a warm skirting board or are familiar with the peculiarities of its operation firsthand. Interested in the question, will there be extraneous sounds such as clicks when heating / cooling, gurgling of the coolant, etc.? The fact is that I have a keen ear and can wake up from any rustle. In one room, for some unknown reason, an aluminum radiator clicks - it takes out the brain in full.
As for me, it all depends on the manufacturer. Buy original products like Chemo Termbord (Austria) and there will be no annoying noise. If we take cheap handicrafts from Chinese or Russian manufacturers, then it is unlikely to do without "music".